By that logic, if I smoke, am I really infringing on your rights? If I fly in a plane, which produces more smog than anything, is that wrong? If I buy a new car every year (again, studies show that about 25% of a car's carbon footprint is produced at the factory) is that infringing on your rights?
Where does it end?
When is there enough "equality" for all?
Again, if Californians truly valued air quality over having to go through all the smog check stuff, than why does the government have to force it on people?
I don't know ANYONE that supports smog checks when you ask them except the guys that own the shops that do the checking.
It's like taxes. It's great to raise them when someone else is paying the extra chunk.
If you smoke in an elevator while I'm in it, then you are infringing on my right. If you smoke in a car with your kids in it, you are infringing on their right. If you smoke in a public place... you start getting into a gray area. Where does it stop? It doesn't. It's a constant debate to find a balance about individual rights and how they infringe on others. Individual rights are not absolute.
Californians do value air quality. That's why we have smog checks. And our air has become cleaner even as our volume of cars have increased.
I support smog checks. I don't own a smog shop. I am not even in the industry. I own 7 cars that require smogging every 2 years. It's a good thing. And I am not an exception. With no smog check, people would be neglecting the maintenance of their cars, spewing pollutants in the air and cause a major health catastrophe. With a smog check, my 97 Z3 will still be spewing 4000 ppm of Nox into the air and I wouldn't even know it.
But I also support the exemption of older cars because their impact is small and they are driven infrequently. Data shows that miles driven by cars 76 to 81 are still too high to have them exempted from smog checks. It's not a conspiracy. It's not a special interest group looking to screw people, it's not a bunch of radical socialists that want us all to drive Priuses and ride bicycles. We're not turning into China. (Have you seen the pollution in China???) We just want clean air.
Ultimately, like it or not, it works. Smog checks and smog regulations have allowed us to have cleaner air AND 240 hp out of a 2 liter motor, with practically no emissions and 30+ MPG.
Like taxes, people don't like smog checks. They are inconvenient and can be expensive. But they are necessary.