thanks guys, I had the outer pieces done by a guy in Washington and he shipped them to me. He does a lot of recover jobs for the VW guys so luckily he didn't need my old ones as a template. His company name is JJ Custom Interior and if you're not in a rush, I would highly recommend. I'm not saying he's slow, he'll tell you up front he's super busy so that's not necessarily a critique, just an observation. Just be sure to try to pin down a timeline. The stitching is top notch, it looks really nice and professional, and there is no bunching anywhere along the seams. He can do lots of different options, different colored stitching, etc. I almost did tan stitching, but I figured it would eventually get dirty since this is my daily driver, and I want to keep the seats "versatile" since they may go in another car some time. He has recovered plenty of other Recaro seat models, you can see his work on his website, he has closeups, etc.
I had the centers done locally. My wife was going to do them because she does sewing/crafts as a hobby and the pattern is pretty simple, but she decided she would rather have someone else bear the brunt of my criticism. The guys' name was Amadeus on Manhattan Beach Blvd in Lawndale, not too far from where I live in Redondo. He was ok, but I ended up having to go back over there to discuss next steps more than once, as if it wasn't already a pretty straight forward job (but what do I know about upholstery) so that was kind of annoying to me. They look great though. My only critique would be the corners of the tan centers stick out a little at the top, but I'm probably the only person it bothers. Also, you can see that the centers look a little "puffy", but that will change once they're a little "lived in". I drive my car less than 50 miles a week, but it's a daily, I just don't go far. If I had to do it over, I would probably have JJ Interiors do the centers as well just because of their familiarity with them.
It's hard to pinpoint a price because I spread the costs over a long period of time and there were lots of random bits such as the new Recaro badges in the center pieces I had put in, as well as the lower driver's side seat bolster foam needed replacing, etc. I would probably rather not know the total cost.
I can tell you that I paid $300 for the seats in almost mint condition which seems to be pretty standard on craigslist and vwvortex.com. You can probably resell the fabric and power bases if they're in good shape and recoup some of the money.