Round Tail Light Gasket refresh

[mgben]

I used the search function and did not get many hits, 

When I tear into my tail lights for refurbishing, has anyone used the URO lens gaskets 63-21-1-351-664?

Or is this a case where an Old OEM beats a new aftermarket? and are the new BMW branded ones as good as old, (or just URO with a BMW sticker on the bag),

Thanks in advance, I have some water streaks near one of my tail lights so I am anticipating finding something going on unless it is just my nasty trunk seal. 

[Mike Self]

Those tail light gaskets are pretty compressible, so unless the URO ones are very poorly made, they should seal properly.  I bought their sunroof weatherstripping (URO branded, from Rock Auto!--very reasonably priced) and it looks identical to the factory stuff.  

 

Most of the noted problems with URO products have been with windshield/backlight gaskets, and door perimeter gaskets.  

 

mike