Hi,
Currently Im running a 242 4 speed box (Ratios 3.764 2.020 1.320 1.000) with a 4.45 ratio diff in my club rally car. 3rd & 4th gear are quite well suited to the type of events I do, but 2nd is really a bit low. This coupled with the fact the the box is somewhat past it's use by date has had me looking at alternatives.
So far my options appear to be,
235/5 5 speed (2002) Ratios 3.368 2.160 1.580 1.240 1.000
Pro's Straight forward fitment, nice set of ratios
Con's Rare as rocking horse sh*t!, Have a reputation as being fragile
Price ?? - I've never seen one up for sale.
245/4 BN 5 speed (E21) Ratios 3.680 2.000 1.330 1.000 0.810
Pro's Straight forward fitment
Cons Somewhat hard to find here in New Zealand, I guess If I looked hard enough I could find one, No real improvement in ratios.
Price ??
240 5 speed (E30) Ratios 3.720 2.020 1.300 1.000 0.800
Pro's Fitment should be Ok, there's the issue with no speedo drive but as I run an E30 diff I'm sort of part way there, Cheap
Con's No reall improvement in ratio
Price probably a couple of hundred NZ$ for the box
Metric Mechanic Type 242 CR Ratios 2.981 1.617 1.330 1.000
Pro's Straight forward fitment, nice set of ratios, don't need to modify drive shaft
Cons Somewhat expensive by the time it's shipped out to NZ,
Price NZ$ 6200
Get some gears cut locally Ratios 2.981 1.617 1.330 1.000
Pro's Straight forward fitment, can choose ratios, don't need to modify drive shaft
Con's The learning curve could be very very steep,
Price $NZ 2500-4000
Toyota W55 (Celica) Ratios 3.570 2.060 1.380 1.000 0.850
A local company (Conversion Components) does a conversion kit to fit a W50 series box to 2002's and other classic cars
Pro's If I go with the kit, fitment should be straight forward. Toyota boxes have a reputation of relaibility even with much more power engines than what mine is likely to output.
Cons No real impovement in ratios although Quaffe do a close ratio gear set for around 2800 English pounds, Conversion components offer a close ration box but it's my understanding that the ratios are only "close" compared to the stock "wide" ratio box
Price $2768 + tax
Ford Type 9 5 Speed (Sierra) Ratios 3.656 1.970 1.370 1.000 0.820
It looks like this box will fit into the tunnel Ok and I could probably cut up one of my dead 232 boxes to make a bell housing. Many Quaffe gear sets are available for this box starting at around NZ$ 2050 (Ratios 2.390 1.690 1.210 1.000 0.930) They also turn up on local online auctions on occasion.
Pro's The stock box improves ratios a little bit; Good upgrade path.
Con's Its Ford!, I'm sort of on my own in putting it together although I do know of a guy who has done the same sort of thing to a 4AGE powered Starlet instead of buying the TRD parts to upgrade the toyota box. I may need a new hole for the gear stick.
Price A stock box can be had for NZ$150, I may be able to talk a friend into giving me one, A bunch of time & calling in of markers.
*edit - It seems I had the Type 9 & T5 gearbox confused in the original post (both were used in the Sierra) the Type 9 is easier to get here in NZ and has ratios available from quaffe*
So are there any other options I should be looking at?.
I have access to a small but well equipped machine shop, so milling, turning & welding operations aren't a problem.