Looked at the two new options today, one in person in Miami and one with my brother in law's help in Chicago (he knows cars far better than I do).
First the white one:
https://miami.craigslist.org/mdc/cto/d/miami-1973-bmw-2002-euro-spec/7370191107.html
Pros:
Body seems in good shape
Minimal rust and no detectable bondo on body or frame (used the Macartney book to hit all likely places and also most other places)
Nice interior
Motor vin matches body **see below**
Starts, drives, shifts well
Cons:
There was no VIN on the body other than the riveted on plate (see photos)
Car was imported from Bogotá, Colombia (he has a warehouse full of nice cars)
When started from cold a good visible spark jumped from the middle of the motor forward
Steering was hard; much harder than the other 2002 I test drove
Brakes were soft and squeaked badly
Took a good two seconds to start from cold
Hood was hard to close; little roller lever had to really wail on it
passenger door was hard to close
Rear tires seem precariously close to the fenders
Black 'grease' looking stuff inside rear fenders on both sides; owner says it's built up tire shire (hmmmm)
Wonky roll cage
Motor seemed to wobble (?) at least more than the red mystery mobile (see vid)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/5fk2fsseyrzbn9h/IMG_8788.MOV?dl=0
The Red One: (second hand from BIL)
https://www.nsclassics.com/1971-bmw-2002-restored-german-classic-see-video-c-5067.htm
Pros:
No rust, virtually no bondo
Started up easily from cold with a little gas
"mostly seems all original"
Great interior
More stock looking
Cons:
"pretty good oil leak dripping onto the exhaust, need to get that fixed or it'll be a drivability problem
Motor vin number missing but has "X X" where VIN should be; Remanufactured??
No strut brace....not sure how important this is
More to come on this one I will edit.